Geico vs Progressive: Which Car Insurance is Better?
Everyone knows that Geico and Progressive are the two largest online insurance companies in the U.S. But what makes one better than the other? Let’s compare and contrast both companies and see if one floats to the top.
Geico vs Progressive: Coverages and Ratings
The table below compares industry ratings for value, claims service, and customer service, as well as some of the optional coverages offered by both Geico and Progressive.
|Value for Price||79/100||88/100|
|Market share percentage||11.4%||8.8%|
|Mechanical breakdown insurance||Yes||Yes|
|New car replacement insurance||No||No|
|Where you can buy||Can buy online or use a Geico agent||Online or from independent agents|
|Number of agents||150+||30,000+|
|Compare Prices Go|
Geico vs Progressive: Which offers better discounts?
Everyone likes discounts, especially when talking about car insurance. Geico and Progressive both offer a good selection of discounts to help you save money, and the list below shows some of the discounts that are available with each company.
|Defensive driver training||Yes||Yes|
|Pay in full||No||Yes|
|Student away from home||Yes||Yes|
|Seat belt use||No||No|
|Online quote discount||No||Yes|
|Compare Prices Go|
Viewing the tables above, you can see that offerings are similar between both Geico and Progressive. If car insurance discounts are your thing, each company offers a slightly different choice of discounts, but discounts generally do not apply to your entire policy premium. Rather, they usually take a percentage off a specific coverage depending on the discount.
Online or a local insurance agent
Progressive differs a little bit from Geico in how they sell car insurance. Progressive not only sells online, but they also offer coverage through a network of independent agents. Geico has a small number of agents in relation to Progressive, but they have a larger online marketshare. So if you prefer to work with a local agent, stop in to your local independent agent and inquire if they offer Progressive as an option.
Is Geico or Progressive cheaper?
If the cheapest car insurance is your objective, then Geico may be the best choice. Out of the top five largest auto insurance companies, Geico was the cheapest at around $1,100 a year. Progressive was second at about $1,240 a year. Farmers, State Farm, and Allstate rounded out the top five at $1,250, $1,325, and $1,570, respectively.
Who has the best claims service?
If the best claims experience is your goal, it’s pretty much a wash. Both Geico and Progressive lagged behind Allstate, Farmers, and State Farm when it came to customer satisfaction with their claim settlements.
Are both solid financially?
There are a lot of different ways to compare Geico and Progressive, but the two companies are so similar that you really cannot go wrong with either one. They are both solid financially, with good ratings with both A.M. Best and Standard & Poor’s. So you will not have to worry about either one going insolvent and not being able to pay your claim.
How to compare rates
If you want the best auto insurance comparison, we recommend you not only compare Geico with Progressive, but include some independent agents and also exclusive agents like State Farm and Allstate in the mix. Each one has unique discounts and coverages that may lend themselves well to your personal risk profile.
Want Cheaper Car Insurance Rates?
Find the Cheapest Quotes in Your Area
Get multiple rate quotes instantly and find your cheapest rate
Compare Rates and Save
Find companies with the cheapest rates in your area
Frequently Asked Questions
- How Much Does Car Insurance Cost?
- Cheap Car Insurance: Myth or Reality?
- Will a Speeding Ticket Raise My Car Insurance Rates?
- Car Insurance Rates 2018: Why are Prices Increasing?
- How Much Does Car Insurance Cost for a 16 Year Old?
- Which Cars are Cheapest to Insure?
- Does a Teenager with a Learner’s Permit Need to be Listed on my Policy?
- View All Coverage Questions